
Construction guide
Forged versus cast BBS wheels
BBS has made wheels by casting, by flow-forming and by forging, in one-piece and multi-piece forms. The process decides much of a wheel's weight, strength and cost, and it explains why two wheels that look similar can be priced very differently.
- Cast
- Molten alloy poured or pressed into a mould
- Flow-formed
- Cast wheel with barrel spun and stretched under rollers
- Forged
- Solid billet pressed under very high force, then machined
- Main alloys
- Aluminium; magnesium for some forged racing wheels
- Example forged lines
- LM, RI-A, RI-D, FI
Casting
A cast wheel starts as molten aluminium alloy poured or drawn into a mould shaped like the finished wheel. BBS has used low-pressure casting for many road wheels, where the metal is pushed into the mould from below with gas pressure. This fills the mould steadily and reduces trapped air and porosity compared with simple gravity casting.
After casting, the wheel is heat treated to improve strength, then machined at the mounting face, bore, bolt holes and bead seats, and finished. Casting is the least expensive way to make a wheel in volume, and it allows complex shapes such as fine mesh patterns without much extra cost per wheel.
The trade-off is in the metal itself. Cast alloy has a coarser, less uniform grain structure and may contain tiny voids. To reach the same strength as a forged wheel, a cast wheel needs more material, which means more weight. Most of the BBS range for everyday cars, including the RX, RT, CS and CK, is cast.
Flow-forming
Flow-forming sits between casting and forging. The centre and a short, thick barrel are cast first. The wheel is then spun while rollers press against the barrel under pressure, often with some heat, stretching it to its final width and thinning the wall. The worked metal in the barrel gains a finer, more aligned grain and becomes stronger than plain cast alloy, so the barrel can be thinner and lighter.
BBS has used flow-forming on a number of modern cast designs, sometimes described in marketing material with its own process name. The face and spokes are still cast, so the gain is mainly in the barrel, which carries a lot of the wheel's rotating mass. Flow-formed wheels usually cost more than plain cast wheels and less than forged ones.
Forging
A forged wheel begins as a solid billet of aluminium alloy, commonly a 6000-series alloy such as 6061 for road wheels. The billet is heated and pressed in a series of dies under very high force, which forces the metal into the rough shape of a wheel. The process closes voids and aligns the grain along the shape of the part. After forging and heat treatment, much of the material is removed by CNC machining to create the spokes, windows and final rim profile.
The result is a wheel with higher strength and toughness for a given weight. A forged wheel can be lighter than a cast wheel of the same size and load rating, or stronger at the same weight. Forged wheels also tend to bend rather than crack on a heavy impact, though any wheel can fail if hit hard enough.
Forging is slow and the dies and machining are expensive. That is why forged BBS wheels such as the LM, RI-A, RI-D and FI cost far more than cast equivalents. Much of BBS's forged production has historically come from Japan.
Forged magnesium
Magnesium is lighter than aluminium by volume, and forged magnesium wheels are used widely in top-level racing, including Formula 1, where BBS supplied forged magnesium wheels for many years. A small number of road wheels, mostly Japanese-market models, have been offered in magnesium or with magnesium centres in limited markets.
Magnesium needs more care than aluminium. It corrodes faster if the protective coating is damaged, and it should not be heated for powder curing or straightened the way aluminium can be. If a wheel is magnesium, treat refurbishment as an expert job.
Multi-piece wheels
Multi-piece construction is a separate question from casting or forging. A classic three-piece RS has a cast centre bolted to spun aluminium rim halves. The RS II uses a forged centre with a two-piece build. So a multi-piece wheel can have either type of centre, and the rim parts are usually spun from sheet rather than cast.
Multi-piece wheels are not automatically lighter than one-piece wheels. The assembly bolts and the overlapping material at the joint add weight. Their main advantages are flexibility in width and offset and the ability to replace damaged parts.
Weight in practice
Exact weights depend on size, design and load rating, so comparisons should be like for like. As a broad guide, a forged one-piece wheel in a given size is often noticeably lighter than a cast wheel of the same size and load rating, with flow-formed wheels in between. Lighter wheels reduce unsprung mass, which can help ride and handling, and reduce rotating inertia, which helps acceleration and braking slightly.
Do not assume a wheel is light because it is forged. Some forged wheels for heavy cars are built with generous load ratings and weigh about the same as a lighter cast design for a small car. Manufacturer weight figures, where published, are more useful than the label.
Strength, testing and approval
All road wheels, whatever the process, have to pass strength tests before they can be approved for sale in most markets. Typical tests include rotating bending fatigue, which simulates cornering loads over many cycles, radial fatigue, which simulates the load from the car's weight while rolling, and impact tests that drop a weight onto the rim edge. Standards differ between regions; Japanese wheels are commonly marked JWL to show compliance with the Japanese standard, and German wheels may carry approval tied to KBA or TÜV testing.
Passing the same test with less material is the real benefit of forging. A cast wheel can meet the same load rating, but it will usually need thicker sections to do so. This is why load rating and weight should be read together. A light cast wheel with a low load rating may be fine on a small car and unsuitable on a heavy one, while a forged wheel of similar weight may carry far more.
Cost of ownership
Forged wheels cost more to buy, and a damaged forged wheel costs more to replace. On the other hand, they often survive impacts that would crack a cast wheel, and they can be straightened in some cases where a cast wheel would be scrapped. Flow-formed wheels sit in the middle again. For a car that sees rough roads every day, a sturdy cast wheel in a sensible size can be the least expensive choice over time, simply because replacement is affordable. For a track car, the weight saving of forging pays off in lap times and in consumables such as brakes and tyres.
How to tell which type you have
- Markings: forged wheels often say so on the back, sometimes as a forged stamp or the word itself in the casting or engraving. Japanese forged wheels commonly carry JWL and VIA marks along with a forged note.
- Surface: forged and fully machined wheels have very crisp edges and machining marks on the back of spokes and windows. Cast wheels show softer edges and sometimes casting texture in areas that were not machined.
- Model: check the series on the catalogue pages, which note the construction where it is known.
- Weight: a much lighter wheel than expected for its size suggests forging or flow-forming, though this is only a hint.
Which should you choose?
For most road cars, a good cast or flow-formed wheel does the job well and costs much less to buy and replace. Forged wheels make most sense where weight matters, such as track use or performance cars with large brakes, or where you value the strength margin and finish. Classic multi-piece wheels are chosen mostly for their look and adjustability, and they bring maintenance that one-piece wheels do not need.
Whatever you pick, a correct fitment and proper care matter more to the wheel's life than the method used to make it. See the fitment guide and the care guide.
A note on finishes
Forged wheels are often sold with brushed, machined or clear-coated bare metal finishes that show off the crisp machining, while cast wheels are more often painted. That is a tendency, not a rule, and the finish on its own cannot tell you how a wheel was made. Check markings and model information first.
Frequently asked questions
Are all BBS wheels forged?
No. Most BBS wheels for everyday cars are cast, some are flow-formed, and the forged range is smaller and more expensive.
Is the BBS LM forged?
The LM is a two-piece wheel: a mesh centre joined to a separate outer rim. How the parts were made has varied with production period and market, so if it matters to you, check the markings on the back of the centre and the paperwork that came with the wheel.
Is flow-formed the same as forged?
No. A flow-formed wheel is cast, then its barrel is rolled and stretched to strengthen and thin it. The face remains cast.
Can forged wheels be repaired?
Forged aluminium wheels can often be straightened by experts after minor bends. Forged magnesium wheels need special care and should go to an expert.